Review: Pebble in the Sky

Pebble in the SkyPebble in the Sky by Isaac Asimov
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Very satisfying old Asimov, with a solid plot and good action that moves along. My only complaint is the rather drawn-out ending that just seemed to take too long to come to the point, along with Asimov’s trademark idiotic character logic.

I won’t give away anything, but the climax is absurd–with even the threat of such a calamity, the imperial navy would have simply quarantined Earth, or bombarded it. An empire of 200 million planets certainly could afford a few HUNDRED warships to that effect.

Instead, Asimov goes through an absurd amount of fencing between characters that dragged down a great story and made it tedious. Also, I read this one by mistake first; will correct the mistake by picking up the other two asap.

View all my reviews

Similar Posts

  • Review: Nightfall and Other Stories (0)
    Nightfall and Other Stories by Isaac Asimov My rating: 3 of 5 stars A few good ones here amidst mediocre stories. Nightfall is overrated as "the greatest sci-fi story". Asimov is a bit […]
  • Review: Friday (0)
    Friday by Robert A. Heinlein I spent longer than usual reading "Friday" by R.A. Heinlein, pausing occasionally to run a self-diagnostic on how I feel about the issues presented in this […]
  • The Mandate of Earth, Revised Third Edition (2)
    The Mandate of Earth has been revised for the third and final time.  The primary purpose of the revision was to tighten the writing even further while preparing the manuscript for a NEW […]
  • Review: Orphans of the Sky (0)
    Orphans of the Sky by Robert A. Heinlein My rating: 3 of 5 stars I didn't like the characters AT ALL. The setting was kind of interesting (reminds me of Greg Bear's previous novel, […]
  • Review: Four Frontiers (0)
    Four Frontiers by Robert A. Heinlein My rating: 3 of 5 stars Technically, I didn't read this entire book. I read 3 of the novellas previously and switched to this HC edition to finish […]

Leave a Reply